Ask HN: Are Doge, Gundo Defense Companies and Defund Ukraine Meant to Co-Exist

5 points by Collusus96 a day ago

This isn't even a political question, as much as it is an economics one. A ridiculous item in the US budget is defense, and post the Zelensky meeting, there is the feeling that US allies should defend themselves. Hence, they begin to beef up their own defense industries. Given that Defense companies make money during times of war, and the US does not want to be involved in the battles of its allies or be the global peacekeeper, how exactly are these defense companies meant to make money other than dragging the country into war? If the goal is to stop unnecessary government spending, why should the taxpayer dollars be spent on funding defense startups founded by 20-somthing-year-olds? (not that I think their age is a disqualification, just trying to explain what it looks like to someone from the outside). Even for SpaceX, there is a non-insignificant amount of people who would prefer their tax dollars being used for humanitarian aid than space exploration.

I basically asking hwo all these people exist in the same ideological camp without seeing the inherent contradiction other than blatant corruption.

anenefan a day ago

I can at least point to what the US might expect with a defund Ukraine movement -- quickly have [1] hung around it's proverbial neck even if King Trump hasn't a clue.

Thus far apologists are generally writing off Trump's actions as actually an entirely brilliant scheme to settle things or some other nifty manipulation to come at the world's problems sideways and land a couple trick shots that will put the US on top.

As for the rest, all I can say is all the best and good luck, there will probably be more important or pertinent issues in a months time that will overshadow the present.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum

actionfromafar a day ago

SpaceX has tremendeous military potential. Look for "Rod from God".

  • readyplayernull 10 hours ago

    Forget the Death Star, the definitive planet-killer weapon will be a really big rock, how much have military tech advanced in these 10k years!

    • mrighele 4 hours ago

      > the definitive planet-killer weapon will be a really big rock,

      Sounds like The Moon is a Harsh Mistress by Heinlein.